- Speaker #0
One community might be resilient under given circumstances, but with climate change, that resilience might be challenged.
- Speaker #1
Exactly, exactly.
- Speaker #0
And the other way around, vulnerability, from what I have seen from my research, is rarely, rarely passive. Nobody actually who is in any kind of struggle would sit there and wait for somebody to save them.
- Speaker #1
In Antalya, governments are gathered for COP31. It is the first year of implementation of the Bellum Gender Action Plan, adopted last year for the period 2026 to 2034. Gender is therefore on the agenda. The question is what it will be asked to do from there. In energy policy, the instinct is familiar. We count, we disaggregate, we add indicators. But in Europe, Energy poverty is still largely read as the level of the household or a unit that tells us very little about who inside that home goes without heat, who carries the weight of the bill or who decides how energy is used. The gap runs across measurement, across the design of support instruments and, of course, across the way vulnerability is framed in policy debates. when gender does appear. However, it often... arrives as some cliche. So my guest today works exactly on this gap. Sashka Petrova is professor of human geography at the University of Manchester, where she leads Generate, a European Research Council project on gender and precarity at the energy frontier across six countries of Southeast Europe. In a recent interview review with Lynn Zhang, she challenges the assumption that Quantifying energy gender is on its own. enough to deliver progress in a sector still largely shaped by men. So what do our numbers capture and what do they leave unseen? Sashka, welcome to Energetic.
- Speaker #0
Thank you so much, Marine, for the invitation. It's my pleasure to be here and I'm looking forward to our conversation.
- Speaker #1
Great. So. We usually start in the pod, we usually start with a little backstory. You are very well known in the energy poverty and let's say gender sector, but maybe I need to ask you why? What brought you first to energy as a research field? And at what point did gender become the lens through which you reach energy poverty or energy precarity, as you name it, very interestingly? So was there any particular moment? place or in country that shifted the direction.
- Speaker #0
Yes, thank you for that. I think there are two points there. One of them is how I became interested in energy-related issues and challenges. And I think even before I became an academic, I was an activist. I was an environmental activist, as my son would say in the old days, in the olden times. So I have always been interested in issues and problems around equality. environmental equality, inequality. And even during my PhD, when I worked with rural communities, many of them depended on resources that were in the proximity of their homes, especially for space heating. And energy became kind of like a visible emerging theme from that research. And I think overall in my career, I have never had like this. How can I say preconceived ideas? I always try to go with an open mind and because I'm a big believer in empirical research as well. So basically energy emerged as such. And then I became a team member of the Evaluate project, which focused on energy poverty. And again, this idea around injustices, inequality, that was another pull factor for me to become very, very active and also working with colleagues such as Sergio, and you mentioned Stefan and Harriet and Neil Simcoe became like a great opportunity. It was a great opportunity for me to become involved. And then I was involved in the Evaluate project, but I also was involved in another project which looked at how the austerity regime in the UK and in Greece, those different regimes have impacted experiences of... energy inequality and energy deprivation. And with Neil, I remember with Neil, when we were kind of like analyzing the documents, it became very obvious that although gender was not taken in such an explicit manner, it wasn't taken into consideration in the projects, gender became something that was very prominent. emerging from that empirical data. And it was basically data coming from different projects. So that's how we kind of sat down and were like, okay, what should we do with this data now? How should we kind of interpret it? And we had long discussions and conversations and actually writing that first paper on gender, on gendered energy poverty actually became kind of like, I would say, almost like a... starting point or like a new starting point for my research as well and further interest.
- Speaker #1
Yeah, no, that's very interesting because I also had this approach. Like at first, I didn't really think about gender as an angle. And then I realized that there were kind of patterns. There were people who were... more affected, we were more suffering, and of which also policymakers or like policy experts or policy people in general, let's say this way, we're asking more from a certain part of the population without ever taking the time to integrate their viewpoint. Like there was this kind of implicit ask that... women were supposed to do something and I mean that was really also very striking for me when I realized that we were having this kind of conversations about what people should be doing in their home like become more flexible use their washing machine in the middle of the day when actually who does that women and but who were saying you know, we need to have this conversation about moving the washing machine in the middle of the day because there is more stomach protection, etc. There were men, there were only men. So that's also like, I also started with this instinct that there was something missing in the puzzle that we were like overlooking more than half of the world's population, basically.
- Speaker #0
You're absolutely right. And you know, it's interesting when you, because you're just like, Even... When talking about it right now, it was this kind of policymaking and the public sphere, which is very much men-dominated still. And then we're talking about the domestic sphere, which is very much about this kind of gendered inequality in terms of who undertakes most of the chores in the home still, time management, opportunities, missed opportunities. And it's a bit like disappointing because, and that's why actually like in my research and in the research of like many of my colleagues, we try to go beyond that binary, you know, it just energy deprivation is not only about the household or the home and, you know, policy making does not happen, you know, just, it should not have, it should not be in that way. We believe in that kind of permeability between those two spheres. Otherwise, no policies will ever be effective if we don't take into consideration those intra-household dynamics and relations.
- Speaker #1
Yeah, absolutely, absolutely. And I think we can also add another dimension to that, which is like maybe the business sector that develops solutions or invents solutions. I had about six months ago a very interesting conversation about... home retrofit and the like the gender perspective on home retrofitting and uh you know my my guest said something really interesting she said that at the end of the day the if a technology makes or breaks it like just like is adopted in the home is because the woman will be starting using it because she doesn't have time to waste on something that doesn't deliver and i thought okay but do we have like focus group On women adopting a certain technology or not, or I still wonder how and why our policies, our approach, I mean, I mentioned co-op, but depending on our conversation, our climate policies are also, are still so blind to this kind of gender factories.
- Speaker #0
It is actually, there was always this kind of idea that you might have the best technology. But if there is no social acceptance, then no technology will be implemented in the society or at least not up to the kind of the expectations that those designers or like innovators had in their mind where they actually created the technology. So that is another thing because, you know, when we talk about how energy is used, and again, if we go back to inequalities or to energy... deprivation is this kind of indicators that are used that is based on statistical data. So they treat the household as a statistical unit, not as a home. The household is also treated as, as you know, as a black box unit as well. So again, what happens inside of that household is not very clear. That's why I think absolutely right. Yes. I think we need quantitative data, but... As a qualitative, mostly qualitative scientist, I really very much into, you know, exploring the depth of phenomena, social phenomena, challenges. By taking some time to hear people's stories and to actually kind of like submerge yourself in that kind of everydayness and those everyday practices and not reducing people, you know, to basically statistical data. which Which, of course, requires time, requires resources, but also it is necessary. You talked also about technologies, and I just want to say that energy debates are still very much dominantly led by engineers and economists. And we also have this trend now of engineers becoming social scientists. So I'm all for like... interdisciplinarity and us working together as equal partners but i can't be like an electrical engineer tomorrow i don't think that would be a good idea and i don't think it's a good idea for an electrical engineer to makes and to talks about social models and thinking about the society only from a very much like an engineering perspective and i think that's the main problem here if we don't listen to... social scientists who understand society from a different perspective, who have dedicated their careers on exploring, you know, those nuances, we can't actually inform policymaking in a rather, you know, holistic manner.
- Speaker #1
And you're also a very particular kind of social scientist because you do human geography. So what is human geography?
- Speaker #0
Okay, so I'm a My background is very much interdisciplinary. Talking about engineers, actually, I did departmental engineering for five years. But I would say I'm not that much of a very good engineer. My brain always worked more in a kind of social manner. I think geography in general and those geographical perspectives are very much important in terms of where... and how energy is produced, transformed, transferred. It opens questions in terms of like around the kind of the spatial justices and injustices. So it gives us ideas around these kind of spaces and places of inclusion and exclusion as well, how places are transformed. But also it gives us that kind of temporal framework. So basically we have this, we always say, In terms of geography, we always go back to the kind of like three basic concepts. So which is place and space, time and scale. And for us, it kind of starts with that triad of concepts. And I think when you add the social aspects, it's very important because the aspects of justices and injustices, issues around recognition, geopolitics. The flow of kind of the spatial flow of energy, especially these days, is super important. But also I think, you know, thinking about this place-based, let's say, like policies that become so important, which I see them in an interesting aspect because in geography we have concepts such as place attachment, topophilia, like place belongings, the sense of place. So I think geography is actually very... in a way essential in terms of bringing that knowledge that we have in the discipline to unpack some of the ideas. Because, for example, when you have, let's say, a new energy project, like people would like to build a new energy community. So the question is, the first question is where?
- Speaker #1
Yeah, of course.
- Speaker #0
At what scale?
- Speaker #1
Yeah.
- Speaker #0
Over which period of time? Who will benefit and how? Yes. Again, thinking about these differences. spaces because there's like the domestic spaces, what kinds of spaces and places we create, but also who has the right to vote in that. Because I think I see place-based politics in a more like, it would be good if they are more progressive in terms of inclusive.
- Speaker #1
Okay.
- Speaker #0
Then the question is like including local people, but who is local?
- Speaker #1
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. Is it someone who knows everything about the area or is it like the mayor or is it someone who moved in recently and just has this fresh outlook and is like, I can't find my way. I don't know how to take the bus. I don't know where to buy a ticket. So that's really interesting because that overlaps as well with urban planning in a way. And let's say urban... understanding of urban environments as well but of course you don't limit yourself to to urban settings and the rural settings are indeed very very important that's um that's that's very interesting to really see this perspective because you move always from the small from the big which is the geography and the perhaps the even the landscape the land etc to the two the insight into the personal life stories and the home and the power dynamics in the homes, right?
- Speaker #0
Yes, definitely. I think in my research, in a way, actually, I have this kind of understanding. Of course, you have these big issues and problems and you need to justify why you focus on a specific, you know, problem or a topic. But in terms of my exploration, I do policy analysis, I do kind of the perspective, but I'm very much interested in the bottom up as well. So I always believe that kind of unpacking the nuances at the very much micro and meso level, the community level, I think is especially important. Because I believe, you know, even when we talk about, let's say, again, if we go back to energy poverty or energy deprivation. very often is seen as a household level problem. But if we can see anything, especially with climate change and all these new risks, it depends on like where that household is. Is it in an area that is more resilient? Is it in an area where you have more green infrastructures, blue infrastructures, or is it in an area that is like more prone to flooding, you know, to see Thailand, you know, being in a heat time. So I think that's very important. And the kind of the opportunity that communities can help each other as well, it is important. That's why that level of inclusion is more than important, actually, even these days.
- Speaker #1
Yeah, I totally align with you. You know, when I prepared this report for the Urban Commission on Summer Energy Poverty, I prepared it at the beginning of 2025, end of 2024. And basically, the European Commission at the time, the GENERGY, asked me to look into what already existed in EU instruments to help people deal with solar energy poverty, knowing that they were not really a definition of what solar energy poverty is. But then the more I was digging into the instruments, the more I saw that there were instruments existing within the... adaptation policy, so the ones related to climate. And then I came across this term like just resilience. Energy poverty tends to be limiting. It tends to be restricted to some spheres of your life when actually we know that it's very extended. But knowing that the ever-changing climate and the pace of changing climate, etc., puts all of us in this kind of vulnerable position. But some of us are more vulnerable. And some of us are more resilient, right? So I've seen also that the European Commission has launched a EU climate resilience law. It's a project in the making, but that's quite recent. And then they have integrated the definition of just resilience. And so I thought, OK, that's good. But how maybe the energy policy people should also embrace this kind of concept as well, because there are things like in our thinking. that tend to be a little bit too limited when we talk only about energy poverty, when it's about our capacity to bounce back as well.
- Speaker #0
Absolutely. I totally agree that whenever we talk about energy, it's not only about that one sector. I mean, you can't talk about climate change these days if you don't take energy into consideration. The sector is one of the main emitters of greenhouse gases. And the other way around as well. I mean, energy research has been widely informed by, for example, ideas that emerged in other types of research, for example, in water research or in climate change, environmental justice. I mean, these days we talk about, for example, energy justice. It's not like knowledge should not be seen as compartmentalized into silos. That's why I said I believe in interdisciplinary research when we kind of try again to create an inclusive academic communities as well. I think for a long time, first of all, great job on doing the report on summer energy poverty. I think it's very important because even in the past, we talked only about excess winter debts. This summer in particular. The number of actually accessed summer darts were just like in the thousands. That means that during those summer periods, because of, you know, extreme or higher outdoor temperatures, wildfires, air pollution, it became like it led them for, you know, the outcome was unfortunately not very positive at all. Having said that, what we found... For example, out in our research, you know, how you talked about vulnerability and resilience. And there was this idea for a long time that vulnerability is more about like, you know, communities or households or people being more passive and just waiting for somebody to help them. You know, it's just like as receivers of help. And then resilience, on the other hand, was seen. You know, I'm not saying by everybody, of course, but it can also be seen as like, you know what, those communities are resilient or those people, let's make those people resilient. They can do it themselves, you know. So in many cases, the government, you know, government states can say like, oh, you know, they are resilient. They can do it themselves. We don't have to be bothered. but in reality The situation is never like this or that. It's a bit more mixed. And that's why I think the temporal side is very important because, yes, one community might be resilient under given circumstances. But with climate change, that resilience might be challenged.
- Speaker #1
Exactly, exactly.
- Speaker #0
And the other way around, vulnerability, from what I have seen from my research, is rarely, rarely passive. Nobody actually who is any kind of struggle would sit there and wait for somebody to save them. Yes, sometimes maybe people don't have any other solutions and there is this huge despair. But no, I don't think from what we see from our research, there is always like, especially people who have or households that are experiencing, you know, vulnerabilities in different senses, try to do their best to kind of. cope and deal with the situation rather than to sit and wait.
- Speaker #1
Yeah, looking specifically at the project you're working on, for instance, Generate, so it looks at gender and precarity in six countries of Southeast Europe. And these countries have seen rapid investment in renewable energy and housing retrofits. I even saw today that Bulgaria was number one in terms of electrification for the heating. Also because there are a lot of air conditioning systems that are actually spun, so that helps. And that covers very well the summer challenge, basically. So what does the view from these places reveal? Because we tend to have analysis from Western Europe, and they miss a lot of the reality from Southeast Europe. And how does this also connect to your critique of core and periphery thinking in energy?
- Speaker #0
geographies thank you yes so generate is um is a near-sea consolidator selected project but because of brexit at the time it was funded by the ukri which is um which is the the uk you know research and innovation it's kind of a body that provides funding for research for academic research. But that is a I still want to see the project as part of the ERC family, although sometimes feels a bit lonely because we were that kind of, it was like a gap period during which if your project is selected, you go through the entire process of like application selection and everything. But then the funding comes from the national funding. And in a way, and afterwards now, of course, I'm very happy that. The UK is back to all the EU Horizon funding and everything. So my project was the last year when it was selected as one of the ERC Consolidated Projects. It was the last year. And then from the next year onwards. Everybody was part, again, of, you know, this kind of EU funding, including, you know, the UK. The project was in the making for a very, very long time. And it's very dear to me as well, because I applied for an ERC starter grant. I think this is important because people believe that, like, oh, you get this huge grant. It's like, oh, well done. But there is much more failure and rejection. Rather than, you know, just getting big grants. So I applied for the project at the time, like when I was able to apply for ERC research starter grant. I didn't get it, but I was able to basically rework it and reapply for it. But then I went on parental leave. Yes. Child care and stuff. And then, according to the rules, then I was too old. I'm like... too many years after my PhD to apply for a starter grant. I'm saying this because, you know, we talk about gender and we talk about childcare, and these actually moments are very important. So then I'm like, okay, you know what, I'm going to apply for a consolidator because, you know, now things are a bit more different because the ERC changed the rules in terms of like when you can apply for which type of ERC grants. But nevertheless, it took me almost like. 10 years.
- Speaker #1
Wow.
- Speaker #0
And yes, and then it was great. And the project is basically focused on the six countries from the Western Balkans, more specifically. And it was very interesting because at the time, there were all these ideas that that is kind of the new frontier for renewable energy. I mean, I remember there was these ideas like they were mapped like over 3000. small hydro power plants that were supposed to be built in the Western Balkans, the new actually kind of El Dorado for solar energy, all these things happening. But at the same time, it is a region with very high energy poverty rates. Gender is an interesting thing because some of the indicators were not that bad. There were diverse indicators in the six different countries. But the thing was, there were many anti-gender movements as well, and politics happening. And I think also that is a broader reflection of things that are happening in Europe as well. I think, unfortunately, there is this kind of idea and there is a lot of anti-gender violence and stuff happening. So I would not say that it's only in the Western Balkans, but... It was definitely taking place there. And at the same time, there were like the green movements, energy movements working on one side and feminist movements, feminist organizations working on human rights on the other side. So my question was like, OK, so isn't it like environmental rights, you know, the right to clean environment? Or if we go back to the 19th, to the 2019 package, like clean, clean energy for all. And all these countries are aspiring EU member states, you know, EU member countries. So it was like... How can we bring the two together? And that has been the overall idea behind it, but also learning from what is happening when we have these kind of expectations. And these are not only national expectations, but these days, for example, if you remember, there were many protests in Serbia about the extraction of lithium. And that was also an expectation from the EU that these little places will become, will provide some of the resources needed for the green. energy transition. I wanted to explore all those tensions and in terms of like what is happening, who is involved in these processes, how is gender taken into consideration, but not only gender, because these are multicultural societies. So ethnicity, gender, class, you know, rural, urban, how is all of this can come together? How can green and feminist movements come together? to basically unpack the politics of green energy transitions.
- Speaker #1
No, that's really interesting because that's exactly the epitome of what you were talking about, the convergence of topics, the convergence of perspectives as well, and the multidisciplinary approach. And yeah, indeed, when you look at the kind of expectations and pressure and tensions in these countries, I mean, If we take Serbia, so now it's a big nod to Igor, my sound editor, but there were elections only a few weeks ago and the government was finally replaced. But that was, it seemed to have been like years and years of situation that felt suffocating for whoever wanted to move forward on, let's say, cleaner energy approaches and also on more inclusive and more. sustainable practice in terms of social aspects. So that's very, very interesting to hear that as well. Is there anything in particular you would like to highlight about what things you have identified throughout this project?
- Speaker #0
Yeah, I mean, we are actually in the process of like of an intense process of data collection at the moment. So we kind of collected over 120 experts interviews. What I'm actually seeing, and which is very, very promising, is again going back to this kind of agendas converging. So, for example, feminist agendas, agendas around human rights, linking them back to kind of green agendas, energy agendas, which is a very positive thing. Because the thing is, it's not the green energy like transitions seen as a socio-technical. think yes they they can happen and i'm not saying like even under the most authoritarian regimes green energy if it's seen as another way of doing business if it's just like a technical issue it might not be a problem the problem is how those actually policies are translated in the society and who benefits from them so ideas around democracy citizenship you know practices you Then participation, democratic transformation, then the issues actually become more visible. So that's why I think this kind of we can learn, green movements can learn from feminist movements, feminist movements can definitely learn from green movements as well. And for me, the best thing is like whenever we do, this is the last thing that I'm going to say. I talk too much, I know. For example, in the project, what we wanted to do is like not to use the region. in an extractive manner. That's very common, you know, it's like sometimes we go collect data, go back and do our kind of academic research. In this case we wanted, we work with local organizations. I come from the region myself, we work with local organizations but not as a source of information. We are all, we all collect data together. We all do, for example, institutional ethnographies. We all do experts interviews. We all work with, you know, different families and households. And we all learn from each other. For me particularly, I had to unlearn many things and relearn. And what is more important is like everybody's paid for their labor, which is, I think, a very, very important thing. If we need actually to do research together, we need to kind of value. all that labor. So I always say, don't only talk the feminist talk, but talk the feminist talk as well.
- Speaker #1
That's really interesting because it circles back to, let's say, the gender blindness of policies or of product development that really overlook the burden of some people, like especially women, on the households and the fact that they work. It's taken for granted and it's not been given a value, like a fiduciary value per se. So that's really interesting because it circles back to really how maybe like the next frontier of, let's say, gender mainstreaming is about financially sensitive gender. Or how could we call that gender sensitive finance or something? I don't know how that works.
- Speaker #0
Women. budgeting and yeah i mean there are different forms you know there is still what we see like for example we still believe that for example gender mainstreaming is important we can see even after you know the kind of um let's say the new meloni's electoral law for example in italy and gender quotas i think it's still important to believe in those gender quotas for example It's still important to believe in gender mainstreaming. I think it's a good exercise, but we also approach it from a more kind of critical point of view. And as I mentioned, quotas are important, gender mainstreaming processes are important, but only if they are done in a kind of critical analytical way, because otherwise if we just see them as a tick the box exercise, they may not be that effective. But as I said, even those quotas. I think are very important these days because I mentioned the new Melonis, for example, law, and many, many kind of policymakers are even concerned that this can actually affect, you know, the involvement of women in politics in a negative manner as well. So, you know, things that we saw as the given thing, it seems like, you know, there is a constant process of negotiating you know, these processes, decision-making, politics, and so on.
- Speaker #1
Absolutely. And it's really important to see that the gender mainstreaming is not about performative indicators. It's not about appointing one woman as a president, because as you have rightly pointed, it's not having one woman president that will change the situation of women. It can sometimes, and unfortunately, in some very well-known cases across Europe, it can be Thank you. really counter impactful. So yeah, that's very, very important to have this kind of approaches as well and understand that it has to be about more than indicators. It has to be about more than performance reviews. It has to be about really proper strategies and evaluations and circles and feedbacks and loops. Thank you so much, Sashka Petrova, for being with me today on Energetic.
- Speaker #0
Thank you so much, Marine, once again for the invitation. I think many people are thankful to you for providing these opportunities and giving us a chance to share, you know, insights from our work. But also, I think I really cherish learning from you and learning more about your work as well, because we are both researchers. So I think... Keeping the dialogue open is very much important. And learning from each other is very much important. So thank you so much. And I wish you all the best for the future of the podcast, which is great. And I listen to it often myself.
- Speaker #1
I mean, you should. It's only 110 episodes young. So yeah, we still have a lot of conversations to go. And listeners, please don't forget to suggest your... the names of some guests you would like to see or hear on the pod. Also, if you want to sponsor, I'm on Patreon. That really helps. If you find these conversations have a value for you, you can also donate or you can sponsor us or you can just give me five stars on the platform. That really helps, you know, that really helps with visibility. Thank you so much.
- Speaker #0
My pleasure.
- Speaker #1
Thank you so much.
- Speaker #0
I would definitely. you know, support your podcast in any possible way tonight. Thank you. Thank you so much, Maureen. Thank you and all the best.