The Lemonheads have always had a knack for taking classic songs and reinterpreting them in a way that feels fresh, intimate, and undeniably their own. While many bands have covered beloved tracks, few have done it as effortlessly and distinctively as The Lemonheads. Whether it’s their jangly alt-rock spin on Simon & Garfunkel or their stripped-down take on a punk anthem, Evan Dando and company have consistently breathed new life into well-known tunes, making them feel both nostalgic and new.

One of their most celebrated covers is "Mrs. Robinson", originally by Simon & Garfunkel. Released in 1992 as part of the 25th anniversary of The Graduate, The Lemonheads’ version took the folk classic and injected it with a dose of 90s alternative rock energy. With a faster tempo and distorted guitars, their rendition transformed the song into a playful, rebellious anthem that found its own identity outside of the original. It quickly became one of their most recognizable songs, despite not even being part of It’s a Shame About Ray until later pressings.

Another standout cover in their catalog is "Into Your Arms", originally by Australian duo Love Positions. While the song might not have been as widely known before The Lemonheads got their hands on it, Evan Dando’s rendition turned it into a signature track. With its warm, melodic charm and heartfelt simplicity, their version became one of the most beloved songs of the 90s. It’s a perfect example of how The Lemonheads have a talent for finding the emotional core of a song and amplifying it in a way that resonates deeply with listeners.

Their take on "Different Drum", a song written by Michael Nesmith and famously performed by The Stone Poneys (featuring Linda Ronstadt), is another shining example of how they make covers their own. Dando’s vocal delivery brings a raw, world-weary quality to the song, making it feel personal rather than just a faithful rendition. The Lemonheads strip back the orchestral elements of Ronstadt’s version, instead opting for a more intimate, acoustic-driven sound that feels closer to home.

Punk covers also have a special place in The Lemonheads’ discography. Their version of "Amazing Grace"—yes, the traditional hymn—is one of their more unexpected choices, turning the solemn spiritual into a loose, almost irreverent punk-tinged track. Meanwhile, their cover of "Skulls" by The Misfits demonstrates their ability to tap into the raw energy of punk while still infusing it with their own slacker-rock charm.

If you’re a fan of The Lemonheads and their signature take on classic tracks, you might also be interested in The Lemonheads Merchandise. From vintage-inspired band tees to exclusive vinyl pressings, their merch is a great way to celebrate their music and keep their legacy alive. Whether you’re spinning their version of Mrs. Robinson or diving into the deeper cuts, there’s no better way to showcase your appreciation for a band that has made musical reinvention their own art form.

Hosted on Ausha. See ausha.co/privacy-policy for more information.